“Another Life” is a song by the American metalcore band Motionless in White. It was written by vocalist Chris “Motionless” Cerulli, Drew Fulk, and Josh Strock. The song was produced by Drew Fulk and Cerulli and is part of the band’s fifth studio album, “Disguise,” released in 2019.
The song serves as a prequel to “Eternally Yours,” a track from their previous album, “Graveyard Shift.” These two songs tell the story of two people who meet and fall in love in a metaphorical afterlife. It explores the pain these two people had to endure to overcome their past relationships and find love with each other.
In this article, we will delve into a detailed analysis of the song’s lyrics.
Table of Contents
“Another Life” Lyrics Meaning
[Verse 1]
If I can’t let you go will darkness divide?
For the fiction of love is the truth of our lies
We were playing for keeps but we both knew the cost
Now the only way out’s in your heart shaped box
In Verse 1, the singer begins with the line, “If I can’t let you go, will darkness divide?” to express a struggle with letting go of someone. The two people mentioned here possibly met in a metaphorical afterlife, so it seems darkness in hell might divide them at any time.
In the following lines, “For the fiction of love is the truth of our lies/We were playing for keeps but we both knew the cost,” the singer is suggesting that the love they once shared may have been built on falsehoods or lies. The singer acknowledges that they were deeply invested in the relationship (“playing for keeps”), but they were aware of the price they would have to pay for this commitment.
The final line references a “heart-shaped box,” which symbolizes a place where emotions and memories are kept. The singer implies that the only way to find closure or resolution is by delving into the emotions and memories associated with their lover.
[Chorus]
But I hate that it seemed you were never enough
We were broken and bleeding but never gave up
And I hate that I made you the enemy
And I hate that your heart was the casualty
Now I hate that I need you
In the Chorus, the singer expresses mixed emotions about his lover. When he sings, “But I hate that it seemed you were never enough,” he means that he hates himself for not being able to appreciate his lover, always thinking that she’s not good enough.
The following line, “We were broken and bleeding but never gave up,” acknowledges that both of them in the relationship faced hardships and emotional pain, yet they persevered and didn’t give up on their love.
In the line “And I hate that I made you the enemy,” the singer regrets that he has turned his lover into an adversary or someone to blame. He expresses how guilty he felt in the line “And I hate that your heart was the casualty” because he has made his lover’s heart suffer as a result of their conflict.
The final line, “Now I hate that I need you,” is used to declare the singer’s love for his partner. Despite the difficulties and hard feelings, he admits that he still needs her in his life.
[Verse 2]
As we rest here alone like notes on a page
The finest to compose could not play our pain
With a candle through time I could still see your ghost
But I can’t close my eyes, for it
For it is there where you haunt me most (Haunt me most)
Where you haunt me most
Verse 2 starts with the line, “As we rest here alone like notes on a page.” In this line, the singer describes a sense of solitude and quietness, comparing it to “notes on a page.” This metaphor suggests that their current state is like a paused or silent moment in their relationship.
The following line, “The finest to compose could not play our pain,” expresses that even the most skilled composers or musicians couldn’t effectively convey or express the depth of their emotional pain through music. Their pain is beyond what words or melodies can capture.
He continues to sing, “With a candle through time, I could still see your ghost.” This line introduces the imagery of a candle, symbolizing a small source of light and hope. Despite the challenges, the singer can still see the memory he shared with his lover, represented as a “ghost.” It suggests that their connection endures.
The final lines, “But I can’t close my eyes, for it/For it is there where you haunt me most (Haunt me most),” signify the lingering impact of their relationship on the singer’s thoughts and emotions.
[Bridge]
And I hear you now when you said it hurt
But it had to fall, fall apart to work
As I see you now in what’s left of me
Is it too late to plead insanity?
I won’t let go
In the Bridge, the singer acknowledges that he now understands the pain his partner felt in the relationship. He realizes that for the relationship to eventually work or be repaired, it had to first fall apart. He sings, “And I hear you now when you said it hurt/But it had to fall, fall apart to work.”
The singer reflects on their current state and how the other person is still a part of them. The question, “Is it too late to plead insanity?” implies that they might be willing to do anything to fix the situation, even if it means appearing irrational or desperate.
The Bridge concludes with a declaration of determination. The line “I won’t let go” emphasizes that the singer is not willing to let go of the relationship or give up on it, despite the challenges he’s faced.
[Chorus]
‘Cause I hate that it seemed you were never enough
You were broken and bleeding in the name of love
And I hope that we meet in another life
I hope that we meet in another life
I don’t hate that I need you
(I don’t hate that I need you)
I don’t hate that I need you
(I don’t hate that I need you)
I don’t hate that I need you
In this part of the Chorus, the singer reiterates his feelings of regret. He hates himself for thinking that his partner is not good enough, which hurts her so much. When he sings, “You were broken and bleeding in the name of love,” we can tell that the singer is finally aware of the pain he’s caused his lover.
The singer expresses a desire to meet his lover again in another life or in a different circumstance, suggesting a yearning for a second chance. He sings, “And I hope that we meet in another life.”
The singer concludes with the line, “I don’t hate that I need you (I don’t hate that I need you),” to express his desire for his lover and the significance of this relationship in his life.
Deeper Meaning Behind “Another Life”
“Another Life” by Motionless In White tells a poignant story of love, loss, and the haunting echoes of a past romance. The song serves as a prequel to another song they have called “Eternally Yours.” Together, these songs create a story about two people who find love in a metaphorical afterlife.
This song is meant to depict the breakup between Chris and Gaia, who allegedly ended their relationship before the production of this album started.
The lyrics in the song discuss the pain of not being able to have a healthy relationship with someone you love and the sacrifices made in the name of love. The heart-shaped box mentioned in the song is a symbol of their love and also the feeling of being trapped by their past.
In addition to the lyrics, the music video also provides hints about the song’s theme. In the video, we follow a man, played by Stitch D from The Defiled, as he reminisces about the beautiful moments he shared with his real-life wife, Nina Kate, after their breakup.
In the end, the song repeats the idea of wanting to meet again in another life, expressing the singer’s strong desire to reconnect with his lover and redeem his guilt in their newfound love someday.

Jacob Carter is a lyricist. He created the lyrics writing course to teach people how to analyze and write lyrics. He graduated from the University of Oxford with a degree in English Literature, so he’s skilled at playing with words.
He’s also an amateur guitarist, which means he knows music and melody very well. With this background, he’s a great lyricist you can rely on to learn writing lyrics.